Anthropology with an Attitude: Critical Essays (Cultural by Johannes Fabian

By Johannes Fabian

This e-book collects released and unpublished paintings during the last dozen years by way of certainly one of today’s so much distinct and provocative anthropologists. Johannes Fabian is celebrated outdoors of his self-discipline simply because his paintings so usually overcomes conventional scholarly limitations to convey clean perception to crucial subject matters in philosophy, historical past, and cultural reviews. the 1st a part of the publication addresses questions of present serious quandary: Does it nonetheless make experience to look for objectivity in ethnography? What will we achieve after we invoke “context” in our interpretations? How does literacy swap the paintings of the ethnographer, and what are the bounds among ethnology and heritage? This half ends with a plea for getting better negativity in our pondering tradition. the second one half extends the paintings of critique into the prior by way of studying the start of recent ethnography within the exploration of significant Africa throughout the past due 19th century: the justification of a systematic perspective, the accumulating of ethnographic items, the presentation of data in narration, and the function of recognition―given or denied―in encounters with Africans. a last essay examines how the Congolese have again the “imperial gaze” of Belgium via the paintings of severe reminiscence in well known historical past. the 10 chapters are framed via meditations at the relevance of idea and the irrelevance of the millennium.

Show description

Read or Download Anthropology with an Attitude: Critical Essays (Cultural Memory in the Present) PDF

Similar africa books

Citizen and Subject: Contemporary Africa and the Legacy of Late Colonialism

Ebook Description
In interpreting the stumbling blocks to democratization in submit- independence Africa, Mahmood Mamdani bargains a daring, insightful account of colonialism's legacy--a bifurcated strength that mediated racial domination via tribally equipped neighborhood experts, reproducing racial id in voters and ethnic identification in topics. Many writers have understood colonial rule as both "direct" (French) or "indirect" (British), with a 3rd variant--apartheid--as unprecedented. This benign terminology, Mamdani indicates, mask the truth that those have been really versions of a despotism. whereas direct rule denied rights to topics on racial grounds, oblique rule integrated them right into a "customary" mode of rule, with state-appointed local specialists defining customized. by means of tapping authoritarian percentages in tradition, and by way of giving tradition an authoritarian bent, oblique rule (decentralized despotism) set the velocity for Africa; the French go well with by means of altering from direct to oblique management, whereas apartheid emerged fairly later. Apartheid, Mamdani indicates, was once really the usual kind of the colonial kingdom in Africa.

Through case reviews of rural (Uganda) and concrete (South Africa) resistance activities, we learn the way those institutional gains fragment resistance and the way states are likely to play off reform in a single area opposed to repression within the different. Reforming an influence that institutionally enforces rigidity among city and kingdom, and among ethnicities, is the main problem for somebody attracted to democratic reform in Africa.


Scanned, fresh replica w/ OCR

The Congo and the Cameroons (Penguin Great Journeys)

Contemptuous of Europe's 'civilising mission' in Africa, Mary Kingsley's (1862-1900) remarkable trips via tropical west Africa are a outstanding checklist, either one of an international which has vanished and of a author and explorer of substantial bravery, wit and humanity. Paddling via mangrove swamps, warding off crocodiles, mountaineering Mount Cameroon, Kingsley is either admirable and humorous.

Law, Language, and Science: The Invention of the Native Mind in Southern Rhodesia, 1890-1930

Via the Twenties, linguistic and ethnographic initiatives to formalize the language and felony structures of Shona peoples in Southern Rhodesia served to bog down, instead of increase, wisdom approximately neighborhood groups. within the Eighteen Nineties and 1900s, translation and ethnography initiatives have been pushed by way of a desire to deal with neighborhood cultures and include them into the recent church buildings and nation.

Missionary Masculinity, 1870–1930: The Norwegian Missionaries in South-East Africa

What sort of males have been missionaries? what sort of masculinity did they characterize, in ideology in addition to in perform? Presupposing masculinity to be a cluster of cultural principles and social practices that modify through the years and house, and never a solid entity with a common, inherent that means, Kristin Fjelde Tjelle seeks to respond to such questions.

Extra info for Anthropology with an Attitude: Critical Essays (Cultural Memory in the Present)

Example text

How, it could be asked, are we to distinguish legitimate ecstatic experiences from, say, 32 CRITICAL. C O N CERNS those flights of imagination that made Carlos Castaneda's fame and for­ rune? The answer is: We cannot (unless we have some factual information on fraud in a given case). 33 Incidentally, these recommendations for ecstasis make empathy, once a strong term in the critique of positivism, rather pale. They also help to clarify a distinction that is often difficult to make-the one between epistemology and method.

A search of major journals in anthropology since 1980 yielded disappointing results. 1o The one paper that looked as if it might address the issue (Feleppa 1986) approached it in terms of the emies versus eties debate and was (as some of the commentators noted) unable to sal­ vage a truly epistemological question from the confusion that has charac­ terized that debate from its very beginning. Feleppa defined the problem of ethnographic objectivity, so far as he defined it at all, as one of over­ coming ethnocentrism, or of gaining an insider's perspective on a culture.

It is concerned with operations, not kno niques of with the grounding of ethnographic knowledge in some actual relations between knower and known. 14 But that is not yet the full story of the disappearance of objectivity, if such can ever be told. We also need to ask why the critical language­ centered position described above failed to have the impact it should have had. In retrospect, I come up with a fairly long list of shortcomings, but before I discuss some of these I want to offer a general observation: that in ethnography and anthropology the chance to develop a conception of objectivity that is not to be derived from natural sciencel5 hinges on a conception of intersubjectivity as something that is made, rather than given.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.42 of 5 – based on 26 votes